Difference between% i and% d

24

Is there any difference between printf("%d", x); and printf("%i", x); ? I know the two return the same result, does it have some sort of convention adopted to always use %d ?

    
asked by Taisbevalle 12.09.2016 в 20:41
source

3 answers

13

Conversion specifiers %i and %d are interpreted in the same way by the fprintf() family functions, however, they are interpreted differently by the fscanf() function family.

Both are present in all patterns: C89 , C90 , C99 and C11 .

%d is used exclusively with integer decimal numbers, since %i is only used for integers (regardless of whether the base is octal, decimal or hexadecimal).

The %i in a fscanf() is able to differentiate integers by predicates, for example:

  

123 : Decimal

     

0173 : Octal Predicate

     

0x7B : Hexadecimal Predicate

The integers exemplified above will all be interpreted as the decimal 123 .

I hope I have helped!

    
answered by 12.09.2016 / 21:26
source
25

No difference, will produce exactly the same result.

The difference occurs in scanf() and its variations. The %d only allows input of a signed integer in decimal format. The %i allows the entry in hexadecimal or octal format.

The function of scanf() is to receive typing characters, so it always does not receive numbers. What it does is analyze these characters and based on criteria try to convert them to numbers.

So its use alone is very little useful. Usually in C exercises or many simple things, which probably should not even be done in C, is used naively and for this purpose there is no big problem. It is common for people to have other means of inputting data into production systems. Variations read other data sources that have more control and it may be that the content is guaranteed to be valid. Notice what happens when you type something invalid .

When using %d the accepted pattern determines that characters only numeric digits and aggregate symbols, notably the negative sign.

In the %i it is possible to include a prefix indicating that the input format is another (without a prefix the decimal is used), for example 0x , the letters from a to f , no matter the box, are also accepted, since the hexadecimal notation allows them.

Of course, it's not just a matter of which characters are accepted, the conversion algorithm is also different to produce the expected number.

Keep in mind that the input and output data are numeric representations and not the numbers themselves .

To use this format the buffer variable must be any integer type.

Before using scanf() understand How to read from stdin in C?

Documentation

    
answered by 12.09.2016 в 20:44
16

In% with%, both are equivalent (print an integer in base 10). In printf , scanf will interpret the number differently if it is preceded by %i (interpretation as hexadecimal).

    
answered by 12.09.2016 в 20:44